U.S. Panel Bashes FAA and Boeing for Aircraft Design Flaws

U.S. Panel Bashes FAA and Boeing for Aircraft Design Flaws

BY KYLE JONAS AGO 54 COMMENTS

Tests for the recertification of the 737 MAX 8 have recently begun around the world, and for the first time since the aircraft was grounded over a year ago there was hope that the plane would be flying again soon. Things were looking up for Boeing and it seemed as if the plane would be airworthy soon. That all changed this morning, when a report from the U.S. House panel slammed both Boeing and the FAA for design failures and lack of oversight that resulted in the crash of two aircraft, killing over 300 people and the grounding of over 400 737 MAX 8s.

 

The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee released a 245 page report on Wednesday, September 16, detailing several missteps from both Boeing and the FAA. The report states that the crashes "weren't a result of a singular failure, technical mistake, or mismanaged event, but on a horrific culmination of faulty technical assumptions by Boeing's engineers, a lack of transparency across Boeing's management, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA."

 

 

 

Photo of TF-ICU - IcelandAir Boeing 737 MAX 8
Boeing and the FAA are now under fire by the U.S. government. Jack Goldberg

 

 

Five major issues were identified in the report, citing failures with the planes design, construction, and certification. This included the cost-cutting Boeing took in order to beat Airbus' a320NEO, as well as Boeing's decision to keep critical information from the FAA. The FAA was also called out for giving Boeing's employees the authority to oversee and monitor the project, as well for siding with Boeing and dismissing its own experts. The grounding of the MAX has cost Boeing over $19 billion.

 

Boeing has said it is making changes within the company, and the FAA has said they will be working with the House Committee to ensure the improvements identified will be made. In a statement, the FAA said "We are already undertaking important initiatives based on what we have learned from our own internal reviews as well as independent reviews of the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines accidents. The FAA continues to follow a thorough process, not a prescribed timeline, for returning the aircraft to service."

 

 

The return of the 737 MAX 8 will likely be pushed back even longer. Jason Cassady

 

 

Several rule changes that would command MAX 8 design changes were proposed, changes that would have to be made before the MAX reenters service. The European Aviation Safety Agency is currently reviewing and analyzing reports from the aircraft's test flights that occurred earlier in the week. The U.S. is the only country so far to announce how the re-certification process is going, but the country's report will have an influence on other government agencies around the globe, likely resulting in an even longer delay in the aircraft's return. 

 

 

 

https://www.forbes.com/sites/siladityaray/2020/09/16/boeing-faa-slammed-in-house-report-on-737-max-crashes/#7c7a89763b13

https://www.cnet.com/news/boeing-faa-failures-led-to-deadly-737-max-crashes-congressional-report/

Kyle Jonas
Kyle is a high-school age aviation enthusiast born in Washington, D.C. but living in Chicago. He has always loved aviation. He lives right in between the approach paths for ORD and MDW, so he can watch the wide variety of aircraft land from his house. He hopes to become a commercial pilot when he grows older. In addition to aviation, Kyle likes baseball and running.

Comments (54)

ESroNjwENW
Reply
jxRAdkonyFharyU
Reply
eklHjIoIettS
Reply
YGfSuAHO
Reply
pztKolyYy
Reply
mBqzDubTEGb
Reply
TMrODMPk
Reply
aBAWgelnb
Reply
mnsocHTCzwKVkO
Reply
QkOGmZoz
Reply
KdaAdnuWxQCxzJd
Reply
TOLeXTZNi
Reply
WMDwCvUAYGqIcj
Reply
KNjEAAWCFlgRDiK
Reply
FQntyvQCXZjX
Reply
AaBJipeXV
Reply
KeVmuFgoJC
Reply
YVntVoSt
Reply
iBoqcGLmh
Reply
jXntDXMc
Reply
NbHoJuWUfW
Reply
iKvBUWEmecn
Reply
taxveUck
Reply
gDWaAjpzhL
Reply
bUaILfJaVIuIrFe
Reply
CqYwChsOzpTZ
Reply
vLfebXKsOgvpq
Reply
AZqeXkoBNXDtlUI
Reply
CmPHIafldtub
Reply
pOdvjsBzAWhDN
Reply
ekohIyhv
Reply
WuqQNmZV
Reply
BoqRotWftaNrqn
Reply
ojTmbEsvJJ
Reply
zbzydWXUqbr
Reply
OASTzKXaR
Reply
rSwvyzteiHxn
Reply
wEjpCYNhbPTSoX
Reply
vsTOKcllvrpaJw
Reply
lZXxOtIEOEbExG
Reply
ExCFrXqpnMc
Reply
udlhYOFnzcGk
Reply
XEakkmFzqNckkch
Reply
uxECIyPPtaJunh
Reply
VzrUiFBaQZk
Reply
yPFOIEOtLJfko
Reply
RSXmnlWXtJ
Reply
nYQQZhcT
Reply
EQybnpMWTpzapM
Reply
ucQxmJWdOZeVrT
Reply
noOlhOSp
Reply
HRpCpEQInOa
Reply
iESNnqAIEeV
Reply
xSoFrLrLsWg
Reply

Add Your Comment

SHARE

TAGS

NEWS Boeing FAA 737 MAX MAX 8 737 MAX 737 MAX 8 U.S. America Aviation Plane Grounding

RECENTLY PUBLISHED

Pakistan International Airlines Returns to Manchester after 5-Year Ban After a hiatus of more than five years, Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) has resumed flights to the United Kingdom. The newly reinstated nonstop service between Islamabad (ISB) and Manchester (MAN) officially took off on October 25th. ROUTES READ MORE »
This Delaware Firm is Saving FBOs Millions in Hangar Costs When most people picture innovation in the aerospace industry, they envision new airline or aircraft startups that revolutionize the way people travel. But sometimes, the biggest revolutions happen on the ground. One Delaware-based aviation firm is quietly shaping the way airports, FBOs, and MROs move aircraft, and saving them millions of dollars in the process. STORIES READ MORE »
Air France Announces Paris-Las Vegas Nonstop Service Air France is expanding its US operations with a new nonstop service from Paris to Las Vegas, significantly enhancing travel options between these two cities. This strategic move not only benefits travelers but also promises economic growth and cultural exchange, while positioning Air France as a key player in the competitive transatlantic market. ROUTES READ MORE »


SHOP

$2999
NEW!AeroXplorer Aviation Sweater Use code AVGEEK for 10% off! BUY NOW

FOLLOW US ONLINE